Friday, February 17, 2012

Crafton Tull's Web site lists guideline changes for wetland and waterways

Guideline Changes for Wetlands and Waterways

on Oct.18, 2011, under Infrastructure
Wetlands & Waterways: Changes in jurisdictional determination approach will expand protection
On July 31st, the U.S. EPA and Army Corps of Engineers closed the comment period on their proposed guidance for identifying Waters of the U.S. that would be protected under the Clean Water Act. Most are probably familiar with the current guidance that requires a “continuous surface connection” between a wetland, water body, or waterway and navigable waters in order for Clean Water Act protection to be extended and the water in question to be deemed jurisdictional. The most common consequence of a jurisdictional determination for public works projects is the requirement for a Section 404 permit from the Corps. The proposed guidance has stated that it will “provide clearer, more predictable guidelines for determining which water bodies are protected by the Clean Water Act.” They go on to state that “based on relevant science and recent field experience, that . . . . the extent of waters over which the agencies assert jurisdiction under the CWA will increase compared to the extent of waters over which jurisdiction has been asserted under existing guidance.” Because of this assertion, owners need to be aware that project costs and schedules are likely to increase.
Why the change?
The most recent Supreme Court decision regarding the issue of wetlands was Rapanos vs. United States 547 U.S. 715 (2006). In this case, the Court issued five different opinions with no single opinion representing a majority. Justice Scalia’s plurality opinion has served as the foundation for jurisdictional determinations. His opinion contained the view that only wetlands with a continuous surface connection to other jurisdictional waters were protected by the CWA. The agencies now plan to expand the decision making process to include views contained in Justice Kennedy’s concurring opinion. Justice Kennedy’s opinion asserts that a wetland with a “significant nexus” to traditional navigable waters should also be protected, as well.
Significant nexus
The guidance gives insight into when a significant nexus exists. It says “Waters have the requisite significant nexus if they, either alone or in combination with similarly situated waters in the region, significantly affect the chemical, physical, or biological integrity of traditional navigable waters or interstate waters.” These three criteria underlined for emphasis are further explained as:
1) Similarly situated waters will be defined as a tributary, adjacent wetland (i.e. has a continuous surface connection), or is in “close physical proximity” to a protected waterway.
2) In the region is defined as lying within a watershed that drains to a navigable waterway.
3) Significantly affect the chemical, physical, or biological integrity cannot be “speculative or insubstantial,” but no longer is the surface connection neccessary. Now a connection can be justified by sub-surface hydrologic connections and, in some cases ecological connections. The guidance encourages field staff to look for the following examples of how the effect can be substantiated.
  • · Physical/ Hydrology: Does the water provide transport of suspended materials, water retention, or a movement of aquatic organisms, or release of retained waters to other waters?
  • · Chemical: Does the water have capacity to carry pollutants or flood waters to downstream navigable waters? To what extent can the water reduce the amount of pollutants or flood waters? To what extent can the waters perform physical functions related to maintenance of downstream water quality such as sediment trapping?
  • · Biological: Does the water have capacity to transfer nutrients to downstream food webs? Does the water provide maintenance of habitat for resident aquatics species (e.g. amphibians, aquatic turtles, fish or waterfowl)?
The guidance is unclear as to what degree the above indicators must be proven. For example, will it require a specific study conducted within the watershed? Or will academic literature that describes the general benefits of similarly functioning waters within a different watershed be sufficient evidence on which to base a decision. Many of the chemical, physical, and biological benefits of nearly all waters are widely known and accepted. Will this general industry knowledge be sufficient evidence to extend protection? To us, these are the questions that remain to be answered. We’ll continue to seek out clear guidance from the agencies with jurisdiction over your projects, but in the meantime want to make you aware of these pending changes.
You can read the full text of the guidance at the following link, from which the information and quotes above were taken. http://water.epa.gov/lawsregs/guidance/wetlands/upload/wous_guidance_4-2011.pdf
Prepared by: Steven Beam, P.E., LEED AP / Vice President for Infrastructure/ Rogers, AR

Saturday, February 11, 2012

Dan Millican talks about impaired urban streams in Arkansas

Preview sample of short takes to run Sunday through Friday, Feb. 12-17, 2012. You too can do a short take each week FREE at Fayetteville Public Television. Shows run on the Internet site of YOUR-MEDIA and on both Cox Cable 218 and AT&T Uverse 99 several times each week.

Saturday, January 28, 2012

Resident of Illinois River watershed in Fayetteville, Arkansas, reports state-sanctioned pollution of tributary of the Illinois River to Northwest Arkansas Times

Front-page story in Saturday, January 28, 2012, Northwest Arkansas Times by Joel Walsh with photos by Andy Shupe documents misbehavior and lack of environmental awareness of the powers-that-be at the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department. For more photos of that site and many similar AHTD worksites, see Flickr AHTD set of photos: 

All the excuses in the newsstory given by city and state officials mean nothing. There is NO excuse for allowing significant siltation of any stream!

Monday, December 19, 2011

Developers keep chipping away at Northwest Arkansas prairie and former wet prairie:

Please click on individual images beneath the video file to enlarge view of wet-prairie and tree-protection area slated to become construction site.

More than 100 photos of mounded wet prairie parcel proposed as site for convention center on north side of Holiday Inn Express available on Flickr near bottom of urban infill set. A sample of the photos appears below the meeting video. Discussion of the site occurs near the end of the meeting. A slide bar at the bottom of the video allows a person skip over discussion of other subjects.
Please click on individual images to ENLARGE.
View east shows tiny wooded-wetland tree-protection area on low corner of several acres of  remnant of mounded wet prairie.
Mowing vegetation out of swale that carries water north to a creek unnecessary and harmful.
Healthy habitat important especially where it also protects watershed
Existing tree-protection area is best place for natural swale and sheet-flow surface water to soak in.
Ditch and pipe from existing Holiday Inn Express parking lot exemplies outmoded  high-impact water management
Existing stormwater pipe causes erosion of big ditch that sends dangerous flow to swale along road toward creek, increasing erosion and flooding of downtream property.
Natural swale through wet prairie takes water to low, wooded wetland at NW corner of property


Sunday, December 18, 2011

Urban infill, even on the outskirts of Fayetteville, threatens Illinois River watershed






Please click on individual images beneath the video file to enlarge view of wet-prairie and tree-protection area slated to become construction site.















More than 100 photos of mounded wet prairie parcel proposed as site for convention center on north side of Holiday Inn Express available on Flickr near bottom of urban infill set. A sample of the photos appears below the meeting video. Discussion of the site occurs near the end of the meeting. A slide bar at the bottom of the video allows a person skip over discussion of other subjects.





Please click on individual images to ENLARGE.




View east shows tiny wooded-wetland tree-protection area on low corner of several acres of  remnant of mounded wet prairie.




Mowing vegetation out of swale that carries water north to a creek unnecessary and harmful.



Healthy habitat important especially where it also protects watershed



Existing tree-protection area is best place for natural swale and sheet-flow surface water to soak in.



Ditch and pipe from existing Holiday Inn Express parking lot exemplies outmoded  high-impact water management



Existing stormwater pipe causes erosion of big ditch that sends dangerous flow to swale along road toward creek, increasing erosion and flooding of downtream property.



Natural swale through wet prairie takes water to low, wooded wetland at NW corner of property



Tuesday, November 22, 2011

Person

Dear Little Rock friends and folks who might forward this info on to Little Rock friends of their own----

Your   water quality is being put in jeopardy by this decision of the Central Arkansas Water Commission,  and you need to do something about it.  EVERY one of you, IF, of course, you have any interest at all in what you put in your mouth and body.   


http://www.arktimes.com/ArkansasBlog/archives/2011/11/21/central-arkansas-water-meets-on-maumelle-zoning


These links should be forwarded to everyone you know  that drinks water in Little Rock.  

This "political compromise"  by the Central Arkansas Water Commission is clearly one of the most stupid decisions possible in regard to water protection.    If enough people call, write, and/or show up at the final decision making meeting(s), your right to clean water might have a better chance.  The problem in not taking this personally and not acting on this issue is that no one knows what is "enough," when it comes to influencing the outcome of a vote by a governmental body, therefore everyone needs to voice  their opinions.   OR just show up and clap or give a hurrah when someone speaks for the watershed's protection.  Don't take this "political compromise" of your health lying down.

Below are a couple of links to a great site about New York City's watershed.  It is protected by forests, not eroding sediment into the water supply from subdivisions and roads, and it serves millions of people with relatively clean water. The water is tested constantly, and their watershed is understood as a filter and purifier, the total opposite of what the lame brains in central Ark are doing. 

"The success of the program is one of the main reasons why New York City remains one of only five large cities in the United States that is not required to filter its drinking water."

Should you want anything less for your body, your city, and your state than what New York provides its citizens?
Get out there and fight these folks, for heavens' sake!